Edmund deduced that the castle had been attacked by catapults.In a hidden treasure vault/chamber, they found golden chests with many of their belongings (including Father Christmas"" presents, except Susan""s horn was missing) from 1,300 years earlier." He is asked to question a woman who has contacted the police with a different story.The scene ends with a close-up of his notes on a pad: Lucy Chapman, The Retreat.That dark evening at the local downtown club, The Retreat (lined with photos of pin-up girls), Duncan""s girlfriend Lucy Chapman (Dorothy Green), who calls herself a "B-girl," tells Bannion hat Duncan had no reason to kill himself.As the camera panned above them, it revealed Ned""s bloody, neck-slashed corpse in the upper bunk.When Marcie left the cabin to "go pee," Jack started to smoke a cigarette, and then felt a drop of blood fall on him.Although Jake attempts to dissuade the lady-like "Mrs.Mulwray" from pursuing the case with an ironic expression: "Let sleeping dogs lie, you""re, you""re better off not knowing," she insists on his investigation of the extra-marital affair: "A wife can tell.