He became the only person to have won all three Best Director awards in a single year.Some interpreted Liza Minnelli""s win as ""compensation"" for the many Oscar losses that her mother, Judy Garland, experienced.Catherine apologizes that she must leave the party early with her father and Aunt.He asks that he might call at the Sloper house to see her again, and then kisses her hand as she leaves.33 million), and was the highest grossing (domestic) film of 2011.However, it suffered a franchise-worst 72% drop in its second weekend, although it was still destined to be one of the top-grossing films of all-time.The second time is when Joe assists Shane during an uneven fistfight.The stump symbolically represents Ryker, who was once mighty, but now has to be removed.] After they swing axes together and use their own "sweat and muscle," in shots alternating between them, hey dislodge, unearth and uproot the resistant stump to beat the forces of nature.