Edmund deduced that the castle had been attacked by catapults.In a hidden treasure vault/chamber, they found golden chests with many of their belongings (including Father Christmas"" presents, except Susan""s horn was missing) from 1,300 years earlier.You will forgive me if I finish it." Later hat night without any else""s knowledge, Bilbo rappelled out of the gate of Lonely Mountain and entered Dale, where he found Gandalf, Bard and Thranduil discussing the upcoming conflict.The only thing that""s keepin"" the water out is the rust.The lax, popular commanding officer Lieutenant Commander DeVriess (Tom Tully), not even wearing a shirt, also was introduced o the new Ensign.Later that day, Koba expressed his concern to Caesar: "If they get power, they""ll be more dangerous! Why help them?!" Caesar replied: "They seem desperate.